Most owners hire too late, then hire in a panic, then lose the person inside a year — and all three come from never doing the arithmetic in advance. Here is what an employee actually costs, how to tell whether you can afford one, and why the first ninety days decide whether they stay.
In this article
When you can actually afford one
Most owners hire too late, then hire in a panic, then lose the person inside a year. All three problems come from the same source: never doing the arithmetic in advance.
The test is not "am I busy." Busy is a feeling, and every owner of a small service company is busy permanently. The test is whether there is enough consistent billable work to keep a second person productive, measured over the last six months rather than the last two weeks.
A usable threshold: you are turning away or delaying work worth more than $9,000 a month, consistently, and you have at least three months of that person's fully burdened cost in the bank. Below the first number the hire is a bet on demand you have not proven. Below the second, one slow month forces you to let go of someone you just trained.
Count your own hours. If you are working 62 hours a week and 24 of them are field work you could hand to someone else, you are already paying for an employee — you are just paying yourself the worst possible rate for it, and giving up the estimating, selling and follow-up that only you can do.
What an employee actually costs
The wage is the smallest part of the number, and pricing your work off it is how a company hires its way into losing money.
A technician at $26 an hour on a 2,080-hour year is $54,080 in gross wages. On top of that:
• Employer payroll taxes — FICA at 7.65% plus federal and state unemployment: roughly $4,700
• Workers' compensation, which varies enormously by trade and state, from around 4% of payroll in light cleaning to 12% or more in roofing or tree work. At 7%: $3,800
• General liability allocated per employee: $1,400
• Vehicle — payment or depreciation, fuel, insurance, maintenance: $9,600
• Phone, uniforms, tools, small equipment: $1,800
• Paid time off, holidays, any health contribution: $3,200
• Training, licensing, onboarding: $1,900 in year one
Total: $80,480 — a burden of 49% on top of the wage, which is ordinary for field service work with a vehicle.
Then the part that decides whether the hire works: they will not be billable for all 2,080 hours. Realistically 1,100 to 1,250 billable hours in year one after time off, drive time, shop time, ramp-up and the jobs you have to redo. At $80,480 over 1,150 hours, the burdened cost per billable hour is $70 — before a dollar of overhead. Anything you bill below roughly $145 an hour on that person's work is not a thin margin; it is a loss.
Keep reading — free
The rest of this article is worth the 20 seconds
Tell us where to send it and the full piece unlocks right here, along with everything else on this blog.
Rather just talk? Message us on WhatsApp.
W-2 or 1099, and why guessing is expensive
The temptation is obvious: pay someone as a contractor, skip the payroll taxes, skip the workers' compensation, skip the paperwork. It is also the most expensive shortcut available to a small service business.
Classification is not a choice the two parties make together. It is determined by the nature of the relationship, and both the IRS and state agencies apply their own tests — several states use a strict ABC standard that is considerably harder to satisfy than the federal common-law factors.
The factors that matter, broadly: who controls how and when the work is done, who supplies the tools and vehicle, whether the worker offers services to the public, whether the work is the core of your business, and whether the relationship is ongoing or project-based. Someone who works only for you, on your schedule, in your truck, wearing your shirt, doing the thing your company sells, is an employee in substance regardless of what the paperwork says.
Getting it wrong is not a warning letter. It commonly means back payroll taxes, penalties and interest, unpaid workers' compensation premiums, and personal exposure for the owner — plus, if that person is injured on a job, a claim with no insurance behind it. The correct move is to confirm your own state's test with an accountant or employment attorney once, at the start, rather than after a claim arrives.
Who to hire first
Most owners hire a second version of themselves. It is usually the wrong first hire.
The case for a field technician. Adds capacity directly, and the revenue is easy to attribute. Right when your bottleneck is genuinely hands and you have proven demand.
The case for an office person. Answers the phone, books the work, chases the invoices, schedules. Right when your bottleneck is that leads arrive and nothing happens to them — which is the actual situation more often than owners think. A part-time booker who moves the booking rate from 55% to 72% commonly returns more than a technician does, at a third of the cost.
The case for a helper rather than a lead. Cheaper, faster to find, and it doubles the output of your best person instead of creating a second independent one. It works when the job genuinely benefits from two hands and fails when it does not.
The way to decide is to look at where work actually stops. If jobs are booked and waiting, hire hands. If calls are ringing out and estimates are not followed up, hire an office. Hiring a technician to fix a phone problem is a common and expensive misdiagnosis.
One arrangement is worth naming because it is legitimate and often confused with the shortcut: a genuine subcontractor who runs their own business, carries their own insurance, works for several companies, supplies their own tools and is engaged for defined jobs at a negotiated price. That is a real contractor relationship and it is a reasonable way to handle overflow. What it cannot be is your full-time crew wearing a different label.
A year in numbers
A one-truck company hiring its first technician:
• Owner's billable hours before: 1,190 · revenue $214,000 · net profit $71,000
• Work turned away or delayed: roughly $112,000 annually
Year one with the hire:
• Employee fully burdened cost: $80,480
• Employee billable hours: 1,120 (ramp-up, training, two jobs redone)
• Revenue added: $148,000
• Gross contribution: $67,520
• Owner's field hours dropped by 310, redirected to estimating and follow-up
• Additional revenue from the owner's redirected time: $44,000
• Net profit: $118,000
The employee contributed $67,520 directly. The larger and less obvious gain was the $44,000 that appeared because the owner stopped spending 310 hours in the field and started spending them where only the owner can work — quoting, following up and selling.
That second number is the real argument for the first hire, and it is invisible in every calculation that stops at "does this person pay for themselves."
Worth noting what did not happen in year one: the company did not double. Revenue rose 90%, not 100%, because a new person is not as productive as the owner and never is in the first year. Owners who plan on the hire replicating them exactly end up disappointed by a result that was actually very good.
Paying so they stay
Pay at or slightly above the local market. Being 8% under market saves $4,300 a year and costs a replacement — recruiting, onboarding and lost productivity commonly run $6,000 to $14,000 per turnover in the trades. Underpaying is not a saving; it is a payment plan for a more expensive problem.
Be careful with pure commission and piece rates. They raise speed and they raise callbacks, and in some states they create wage-and-hour complications with overtime and minimum-wage calculations. A solid base with a modest performance component is easier to administer and produces better work.
Tie any bonus to things the employee controls. Jobs completed without a callback, membership plans sold, reviews earned by name, on-time arrivals. Bonuses tied to company profit mean nothing to someone who cannot see the books.
Raise on a schedule, not on a threat. A stated annual review prevents the conversation where someone brings a competing offer, and it costs less than replacing them.
The first ninety days decide it
Turnover in small service companies is concentrated in the first three months, and it is almost never about money. It is about arriving to no plan.
Week one: ride along. Not as a favor — as the training. They watch how you talk to customers, which is the thing you cannot write down.
Weeks two to four: they lead, you watch. Correct after the customer leaves, never in front of them.
Give them a written standard. What a finished job looks like, what gets photographed, what gets said at the door, when to call you. Five pages beats five months of correction.
Check in weekly, deliberately. Fifteen minutes, scheduled. Most people who quit in month two had a fixable complaint in week three that nobody asked about.
Do not send them out alone too early. One bad job in front of a customer costs more than a week of supervision, and it damages the new person's confidence in a way that is hard to recover.
Why good people leave small companies
The reasons are consistent across trades, and almost all of them are cheaper to fix than to replace.
No path. Helper to technician to lead to foreman, with the pay attached to each step, written down. Absent that, a good employee's only visible way forward is a different company.
Unpredictable hours. Being sent home at noon in February, or called in on Saturdays with no notice. People with families need a schedule more than they need an extra dollar an hour.
Bad equipment. Working with broken tools every day communicates exactly how much the work is valued.
Being blamed in front of customers. The fastest way to lose someone competent, and it is free to stop.
No recognition of what they fixed. A five-star review naming a technician, read out loud, does more than most bonuses.
Five mistakes
1. Pricing work off the wage. The burdened cost per billable hour is roughly 2.7 times the wage, and every quote built on the wage is built on a number that was never real.
2. Classifying an employee as a contractor to save payroll tax. Back taxes, penalties, unpaid comp premiums and an uninsured injury claim.
3. Hiring a technician to fix a phone problem. If leads arrive and nothing happens to them, hands are not the bottleneck.
4. Hiring with no cash buffer. One slow month and you release someone you spent three months training.
5. No plan for the first week. Turnover concentrates in the first ninety days, and it is nearly always about arriving to nothing rather than about pay.
The five numbers
Burdened cost per billable hour, per employee. The only figure your pricing should ever be built on.
Utilization rate. Billable hours over paid hours. Expect 50% to 60% and price accordingly.
Revenue per employee per month, tracked against the burdened cost. It tells you when the next hire is affordable.
Callback rate by technician. The quality measure that predicts both reviews and rework cost.
Turnover cost per year. Recruiting, onboarding and lost productivity. Most owners have never calculated it, and it is usually larger than the raise that would have prevented it.
A new technician only pays off if the calendar stays full
The hire that works is the one with proven demand behind it. Send us your monthly lead volume and your close rate and we will show you whether the bottleneck is really hands.
Frequently asked questions
What does a service business employee actually cost?
Far more than the wage. A technician at $26 an hour on 2,080 hours is $54,080 in gross wages, and on top of that come employer payroll taxes of roughly $4,700, workers' compensation that varies from about 4% of payroll in light cleaning to 12% or more in high-risk trades, allocated general liability, a vehicle with fuel and maintenance, phone and uniforms and tools, paid time off, and first-year training and onboarding. The total commonly lands near $80,480 — a burden of about 49%. Then divide by realistic billable hours: 1,100 to 1,250 in year one after time off, drive time, ramp-up and rework. That gives a burdened cost near $70 per billable hour before any overhead.
Can you pay a crew member as a 1099 contractor?
Only if the relationship genuinely is a contractor relationship, and that is not something the two parties choose together. Both the IRS and state agencies apply their own tests, and several states use a strict ABC standard that is considerably harder to satisfy than the federal common-law factors. What matters is who controls how and when the work is done, who supplies tools and vehicle, whether the worker offers services to the public, whether the work is the core of your business, and whether the relationship is ongoing. Someone who works only for you, on your schedule, in your truck, doing what your company sells is an employee in substance. Getting it wrong means back payroll taxes, penalties, unpaid comp premiums and an uninsured injury claim — confirm your own state's test with an accountant or employment attorney before hiring, not after.
Should the first hire be a technician or an office person?
Look at where work actually stops. If jobs are booked and waiting, hire hands. If calls are ringing out and estimates are never followed up, the bottleneck is not hands — and hiring a technician to fix a phone problem is a common and expensive misdiagnosis. A part-time person who moves the booking rate from 55% to 72% frequently returns more than a technician does, at roughly a third of the cost. A helper rather than a lead technician is a third option: cheaper, easier to find, and it doubles the output of your best person instead of creating a second independent one, which works when the job genuinely benefits from two hands.